Prior to the COVID-19 outbreak, you might already have had team members working from home, or this might be a completely new experience for you and your team. Working from home is a transition for all concerned and whether managers are seasoned in managing their teams remotely, or new to this, there is much to bear in mind to uphold effective and safe practice when working in this way. In this blog we outline some key considerations regarding remote working.
One of the biggest concerns for managers is maintaining a balance between being supportive of people who are working off-site and potentially coming across as a micro-manager. This is particularly difficult as home working removes the ability of the manager to monitor employees within the usual workplace setting. However, you can strike a healthy balance by considering the following:
Please contact FD Consultants for further information on how such training might be tailored for your organisation at info@fionadunkley.com If you would like access to the full guide for managing staff remotely, then sign up to our newsletter as we’ll be sharing this in next month’s edition. To sign up to the newsletter click here: http://eepurl.com/wc4Zf For organisations looking for employee psychological support, FD Consultants are the trauma specialists and well-being service who will best deliver a reliable, quick, and bespoke support system in the workplace. FD Consultant’s team of accredited specialists will offer ongoing support to help manage stress, prevent burnout and provide specialist trauma care where required, enabling your staff with the tools to cope, and recover more quickly.
0 Comments
Authors: Yasmin Dunkley & Nokubonga Ralayo
Question: “How do you spot participant distress over the phone?”
Summary: This piece of work is a direct response to the literature review “How to conduct remote research with adolescents in South Africa.” That review recognised that in changing how we conduct participant interviews (with phone based modalities) the visual clues and cues which often inform the researcher when working face to face are absent. This means that the relationship between interviewer and participant is changed, and the visual cues that show when a participant is becoming distressed are equally absent. This document starts by listing considerations around phone-based interviews that researchers may need to be mindful of when conducting this research for the first time, including the increased perceived intimacy of phone based interviewing, an increase in blurred boundaries between participant and researcher, and the potential for increased disclosures. It then provides a list of techniques for spotting when participants are becoming distressed, as well as some of the techniques for mitigating that distress. This piece of work continues by looking at some of the principles of self-care, and seeks to empower researchers to stop when they feel uncomfortable or at risk of vicarious distress. The intended audience of this piece of work is research assistants directly working with the Hey Baby, Mzantsi Wahko and TAG teams in the Western and Eastern Capes of South Africa. This document is intended to be a living document, to support field workers carrying out their remote research. The document will form the basis of ongoing training, supervision and debriefing around non-visual cues of distress, as well as support qualitative and quantitative phone based research methods. We are living through an unprecedented time. We decided to create this document to be proactive in supporting our team during the COVID19 epidemic and beyond. We recognise that field workers, ultimately, have the knowledge, skills and expertise to conduct research. This document is a tool to support and complement the good work that they are already doing. Moving forward and recommendations: This section briefly outlines some already decided steps, and some recommendations for the management of Hey Baby, Mzantsi Wahko and TAG teams to consider when thinking about the future direction of this piece of work.
Considerations Research assistants will be using phone based interviewing for the first time with the Hey Baby and TAG research projects. In switching from face to face work to remote work, it is important to note that the relationship between participant and researcher can change. Here are some of the key considerations for researchers to be aware of before conducting these interviews.
How do we identify distress over the phone? According to Dictionary.com, distress is “great pain, anxiety, or sorrow; acute physical or mental suffering; affliction; trouble” or a “state of extreme necessity or misfortune.” It can be the result of poor mental health, historic abuse, or even physical pain, which could be triggered by the interview process. Not all distress will require a referral. Sometimes the simple process of disclosing feelings can help the participant feel supported. Without visual cues, it can seem harder to identify when our participants are distressed with phone-based interviewing, however there are some techniques for assessing how participants are doing during interviews. 1.Assess the nonverbal: You will need to assess unspoken language to see how participants are doing. Ask yourself “Does the participant seem reluctant to respond?” 2.Tone of voice is a powerful form of non-verbal communication: Listen to the tone of the participant’s voice and listen to the words that they use, what could be “flag” words that identify all is not well? Listen for pauses, breathing, changes in voice patterns, background noises, as all of these will become significant. Listen to the tone and pace of the words being used, and the little inflections in the voice. On the phone, we can hear the slightest change in movement from our participants, what does that movement mean about the emotional state of the person you are speaking with? 3.Consistently check-in with your participants: Ask them “are you still OK?” If a participant sounds vulnerable, they may not speak up about it, so you can choose to ask them how they are feeling. To really find out what’s going on, we need to engage in a conversation with our participants, ask them how they are, truly listen to the answer, and encourage them to open up if they feel comfortable. Your pauses or silences for some young people will be difficult, and participants may wonder if you’re still there or whether you’re still listening. You will need to find a balance between letting the participant know you’re still present, whilst allowing the important silence for the participant to respond to your questions. Minimal encouragements can help to support this (mmhmm) or you might want to say more, ‘I’m still here…’ 4.Practice active listening: You will have been trained on some of the techniques of active listening (including the five key techniques to show you are listening. These are so useful when conducting phone based interviewing.
The best way that you can understand whether you participant is OK, is by listening to them, and asking them. Strategies to deal with distress: Often it will become clear very quickly if a participant is distressed. What can be more challenging is understanding what to do when a participant is distressed. There are levels to this, as if a participant is at risk of immediate harm, this is an emergency situation and requires immediate action in line with the HUBs safeguarding policies. Referrals are not discussed in this document, as they are covered in-depth in a separate referral pathways document. The referral pathways document specifically looks at what to do when a participant has made a disclosure in the following areas:
Techniques for managing distress:
What if the participant hangs up? This is a real possibility with phone based research. Debriefing can help you explore how you feel if a young person exercises their right to flee from an interview, or their emotions, by hanging up a call. Those who feel the need to escape or remove themselves from a difficult feeling or situation may find it easier to do so by putting down the phone than they would do walking out of an interview. It is important to consider what you would do and how you might feel ahead of this could, so you can mentally prepare for the eventuality if it does happen. What will it be like if you aren’t able to reconnect? When does a risk assessment come into play? How do you determine whether this was about their right to respond to a difficult feeling to look after themselves or whether there is something of a more serious nature at play that needs to be acted upon? These are questions to explore in training, debriefing and in supervision. Self-care strategiesSelf-care is very important when you are engaging with participants. This includes practicing self-awareness; when you feel overwhelmed and you are not OK in the middle of a conversation, don’t be afraid to take a step back. You can make any excuse to stop the call and find the time to look after yourself. Some of these measures may help you look after yourself during an interview: 1.Set clear boundaries: When you call your participant you introduce yourself and the purpose of your study – it’s a type of contracting. Do not be afraid to revisit the purpose of your call. We are not trained counsellors, therefore when you can sense the conversation is getting deeper than you are able to hold in your capacity, be honest with the participant, and tell them you can hear they are going through a lot, but that you are not a trained counsellor. You can then explore with them some referral pathways. Offer that resource to them rather than trying to bear the burden yourself. 2.Keep your team updated and debrief: It is OK to not know what to do. Take the time with your manager or a colleague and discuss your interviews. 3.Take time for you: Take a step back often. Being on the front line means being in the heat of the moment, and we always need time to reflect and flush out the heat. Take your time and give yourself space when interviewing participants. Take a break when you feel frustrated. Know that you are allowed to pause your interviews to collect yourself. Stop, go for a walk, whatever makes you feel relaxed. When you cannot keep calm, make any excuse to take your break and find that calmness. You don’t have to let it all in and listen and you are not there to fix all of the problems that you will hear. You need to look after yourself, so that you can be the best researcher possible for your participants. 4.Use a counsellor or call a helpline: Do not be afraid to use the services on offer for yourself. In many ways, hearing what are participants are going through will remind us of what has been happening in our own lives. You are going through this COVID19 experience as well. Do not be afraid to reach out. 5.Find out how to build your resilience and develop a resilience toolkit: Attached to this document, is an article about the RESPECT model. This is a model of self-care that suggests ways of building ourselves up to be able to withstand or manage stressful or traumatic experiences. The model suggests that we find ways to do the following when we feel overwhelmed:
6.Finally, be kind to yourself: You are not going to get it right all of the time. It is OK to make mistakes, and we can all learn from them. MIND Resources
References The content in this document was informed by the following professionals and agencies, and we are grateful for their support.
For organisations looking for employee psychological support, FD Consultants are the trauma specialists and well-being service who will best deliver a reliable, quick, and bespoke support system in the workplace. FD Consultant’s team of accredited specialists will offer ongoing support to help manage stress, prevent burnout and provide specialist trauma care where required, enabling your staff with the tools to cope, and recover more quickly. “85% of individuals felt stigma was still a problem in the workplace and prevented people from reaching out for necessary support” (Dunkley, 2018)
Instigating mental health peer support programmes into an organisation can help challenge stigma and create a healthy organisational culture. Peer support programmes are cost effective and can help reach staff that are in remote locations or have limited access to psychosocial support. “85% of individuals felt stigma was still a problem in the workplace and prevented people from reaching out for necessary support” (Dunkley, 2018). Another factor preventing staff from reaching out for support is due to feelings of ‘guilt’. One aid worker informed me it took her five years before she reached out for help after suffering from vicarious trauma symptoms. Due to the time it took her to get support her vicarious trauma had now become a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder. She said to me, ‘I felt guilty if I informed anyone I was suffering. How could I complain, when I was faced with such despair in my work, and others were suffering from so much more than me?’ A manager that had gone through organisational restructuring and had to make some of his team’s roles redundant, had found the process very stressful. Previously he had been working to a tight deadline to complete a campaign he was working on supporting individuals who had been falsely imprisoned. By the time he came to see FD Consultants his stress had turned into burnout. ‘I would find myself bursting into tears or be overcome with anger at the slightest thing. I felt constantly on edge, had difficulty sleeping and had awful vivid thoughts of people trying to get to me. It took me several months before I admitted to myself, I need help.’ Peer support programmes train peers to offer early and good quality support which can prevent an individual’s vicarious trauma developing into post-traumatic stress disorder, or stress developing into burnout. If someone goes off work with stress-related issues they may be off work for a few days, if someone goes off work with burnout, they may be off work for weeks or even months and may never return to the workplace. Additionally, research shows that when an individual receives support early, they will recover quicker, therefore preventing long-term health problems. Training mental health peer supporters in the workplace enables staff to feel equipped to recognise the warning signs and symptoms of ill-mental health in themselves or their colleagues and feel prepared to offer the initial support and signposting to specialist psychological services if necessary. In our workshops we provide simple and practical tools to support individuals in distress. The training also builds individual’s resilience and understanding in how best to support themselves when under high levels of stress, whether from workload, the nature of the work, tight deadlines, a rapidly expanding organisation, or organisational restructuring. I visited an Occupational Health service in Nairobi to train staff in responding in a crisis. During the training I referred to the word, ‘Ubuntu’ (a Nguni word and Southern African philosophy) – ‘I am, because we are’. Healing from workplace psychological challenges should be a collaborative process; we need support from mental health informed organisations, with implemented best practice psychological support services and well-trained mental health peer supporters. This alone can create a healthy and resilient organisational culture. Van Der Kolk, a psychiatrist, also refers to the word Ubuntu: ‘my most profound experience with healing from collective trauma was witnessing the work of the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which was based on the central and guiding principle of Ubuntu…. that denotes sharing what you have, as in “my humanity is inextricably bound up in yours.” Ubuntu recognises that true healing is impossible without recognition of our common humanity and our common destiny.’ (Van Der Kolk, 2014, p. 349). I leave you to reflect on how well your workplace integrates the word ‘Ubuntu’ into the values and principles of the organisation. If you want to help to implement a peer support programme into your organisation, please email info@fionadunkley.com. Fiona Dunkley (Founder of FD Consultants) For organisations looking for employee psychological support, FD Consultants are the trauma specialists and well-being service who will best deliver a reliable, quick, and bespoke support system in the workplace. FD Consultant’s team of accredited specialists will offer ongoing support to help manage stress, prevent burnout and provide specialist trauma care where required, enabling your staff with the tools to cope, and recover more quickly. (Trauma and Vicarious Trauma Awareness Workshop)“When we are impacted by trauma, we may feel chained, restricted, fragmented, subdued, and penned in by unmoveable obstacles. The process of Post-Traumatic Growth can free us from those chains.”
(FD Consultants) The image of an elephant, in its original habitat, roaming through the Kruger Park, South Africa, is imprinted on my mind today; watching the magnificent stillness, at sunset and sunrise, as the red blanket radiates over the landscape. I have also witnessed elephants in India during festival times, although equally magnificent creatures, this was a harder observation, as the elephants had large chains around their ankles and had become subdued to the loud bangs of celebration all around them. In Hinduism, Ganesha, one of the most worshipped Gods, is easily recognised by his elephant’s head. Ganesha is characterised as the remover of obstacles. The large elephant headed deity, removing that which is negative in its path. When we are impacted by trauma, we may feel chained, restricted, fragmented, subdued, and penned in by unmoveable obstacles. There is a great deal of research now that shows when we recover from trauma, we can experience post traumatic growth. My book “Psychosocial Support for Humanitarian Aid Workers: A Roadmap of Trauma and Critical Incident Care” (Dunkley, 2018), is full of case studies of aid workers who have suffered acute stress, burnout or Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). The last chapter focuses on each and every one of these stories and describes a process of ‘post traumatic growth’, where many of these individuals have gone on to use their experiences to help others. My own story of post traumatic growth is described in my book, and perhaps is the main reason my work specialises in trauma care. I am able to sit in the most uncomfortable places and hold hope that each individual will recover. I strongly believe everyone can recover from trauma with specialist support. Unfortunately, there are many therapists that state they work with trauma but are not specialists. The risk is that someone’s recovery of maybe six sessions, develops into years of talking therapy. Many of our associates at FD Consultants offer EMDR and TF-CBT trauma therapy (as recommended by WHO, APA and NICE). At FD Consultants we offer a half-day ‘Trauma and Vicarious Trauma Workshop’. Staff that are identified in ‘high risk’ roles, possibly through the location or intensity of their work, or the risk of being exposed to traumatic material, whether directly or indirectly, would benefit from this workshop. It is a more in-depth look at the neuroscience of trauma, physiology, symptoms and building resources, than our stress management workshop. There are many myths and misunderstanding about how to best treat individuals who are traumatised. There is also a great risk of re-traumatising someone, who is suffering from trauma symptoms, without the knowledge from this workshop. Therefore, this workshop is also helpful for managers supporting staff who may be suffering trauma or vicarious trauma, and staff who have been impacted by a critical incident. Over the last few years at FD Consultants we have supported staff who have experienced sexual violence, hostage and kidnapping, civil unrest, assault, bullying and harassment, road traffic accidents, natural disasters, death of colleagues, and the impact of organisational restructuring. We have supported organisations’ whose staff have been impacted by the Ethiopian plane crash, conflict in Yemen and Syria, earthquakes in Indonesia, floods in India, the Persian Gulf crisis, further Ebola outbreaks, and the Myanmar Rohingya refugee crisis. Last year, due to Coronavirus, we created a series of workshops and services for organisations to specifically take care of their staff through this unprecedented and challenging time. But not only do we, as FD Consultants, recognise the direct impact of trauma, we also make sure organisations do not overlook the corrosive impact of vicarious trauma, sometimes known as secondary trauma. Research states that by listening to stories of trauma, we can start to be impacted by trauma symptoms, especially if we are empathic or intuitive, as our mirror neurones start to fire in the same way as the person telling us the story. Listening to the media or reading traumatic material can impact us vicariously. Organisations do not necessarily know what lies in someone’s past and whether they may have a deep-rooted trauma that can be triggered by the work they do. We have carried out psychological debriefings for staff who completed research on human rights issues, such as torture, false imprisonment, sexual violence or suicide. We support researchers, journalists, IT social media analysts, and legal staff. We have also helped frontline staff, such as reception staff, who may experience direct threat in the office, or indirect threat through social media or email. For one large international NGO (non-governmental organisation), we have started facilitating ‘threat communication’ workshops alongside security consultants, as personal and organisational threat is significantly increasing on social media. If you want to find out more about our workshops, please email info@fionadunkley.com. If you are working in an environment where there is risk of being exposed to traumatic material, or you are managing staff that are at risk, please become trauma informed. Fiona Dunkley (Founder of FD Consultants) For organisations looking for employee psychological support, FD Consultants are the trauma specialists and well-being service who will best deliver a reliable, quick, and bespoke support system in the workplace. FD Consultant’s team of accredited specialists will offer ongoing support to help manage stress, prevent burnout and provide specialist trauma care where required, enabling your staff with the tools to cope, and recover more quickly. FD Consultants Stress Management and Resilience Building workshop“Try to give yourself the gift of time, even for one day, and listen to your inner truth when sitting in your silence.” (FD Consultants)
The beginning of my 2020 was starkly different from the beginning of my 2021. At the time little was I to know we were about to head into a global pandemic. When the boarders were freely open, I was fortunate to start 2020 in Kerala, South India on a working holiday. My 5am alarm clock was music and chanting coming from the nearby temple. I would take an early morning stroll, before the heat of the sun zapped my energy, through the local village to the fishing port. Here, time seemed to stand still, as I watched the fishermen rhythmically lowering and raising their large fishing nets into the water, intuitively knowing when the time was right to catch their fish. Watching these men created a space for a pause; a moment deep inside myself. I took a deep breath in as the nets lowered, and a completed breath out as the nets rose. A technique I have needed to turn to often whilst supporting myself through this pandemic. I have had so many clients say to me in their assessment sessions, “I feel like I haven’t breathed properly for years”. How precious our breath is and how we take it for granted. It is our life source and so much healing and good health comes from breathing properly and mindfully. One exercise I teach participants in FD Consultants stress management workshop is to take a deep breath in and make the out breath longer than the in breath. This activates our parasympathetic nervous system, helping us to relax. For one client it took a full month before she could make her out-breath longer than her in-breath, which showed me she had been living life in the stress lane for a very long time. At FD Consultants we offer a half-day Stress Management and Resilience Building workshop. We recommend that “ALL” staff who join an organisation where workload and work pressure is high, or there is a risk of being exposed to traumatic material, whether directly or indirectly, should attend this workshop as part of their induction. Staff need to be given the space at the very outset to build strategies for managing stress, and to recognise the signs in themselves and their colleagues. We want to encourage organisations to build into their framework preventative measures to best support their staff. These workshops improve an organisation’s culture and create a healthy and resilient organisation. By giving staff the tools to recognise the signs of stress, trauma, burnout or compassion fatigue, we enable them to reach out for support when necessary. Research has shown that the earlier someone gets support, the quicker they will recover, and this can prevent long-term illness. I had time to digest a healthy dose of reading material whilst away. One of the books I read was, Joy on Demand, by Chade-Meng Tan. He believes, "we can develop major mental skills like the ability to access joy on demand, and in doing so, improve every single aspect of our lives. The mental equivalent of physical exercise is meditation" (Tan, 2016). By learning techniques to calm the mind, we can be more prepared during stressful times, and keep ourselves mentally well. Another book I enjoyed reading was Momo (Ende, 1984), a beautiful story about where time comes from. It is full of poignant messages about what we value in life, "time is life itself, and life resides in the human heart." In the story “time thieves” strip humans of time, humans start working harder and faster, and avoid at all costs sitting in silence. It is not until we learn to sit in our own silence that we can change unhealthy patterns, as the noise of “doing" drowns all other reason out of the mind. I have heard people attend our workshops stating that they never have time for themselves, as if it is something they have just come to accept. We need to listen to our self-talk and hear the warning signs loud and clear. If we are saying we never have enough time for ourselves, then something has to change, or we will become ill. It took me a week into my break before I could fully relax. I found myself feeling "guilty," and saying to myself, "I should be doing more". One of the topics we cover in the stress management workshop is the eight common stress thinking patterns, the eighth pattern being stuck in thinking of what we "should", "ought to", and "must" be doing. Many of the Keralan people I met through my work seemed to have embodied this wisdom. Lakshit, a life coach, said to me one morning "the more you chase the money, the unhealthier your lifestyle becomes, and the more you have to spend on putting yourself right again". His statement reminded me of the stress cycle, the longer we are in it the harder it is to see, and the more difficult it is to break. He also taught me to focus on the "experience" I offer to people. My dream is to setup a retreat, but at present I can’t work out how that can happen financially, but an “experience” can be gained anywhere, and anytime through human connection. His statement helped me to reframe my thinking by bringing my mind back to appreciating the present, rather than stretching too far into the future. Another beautiful soul I met who manages a small Airbnb by cooking, cleaning and driving his Tuk Tuk, Mr Jobin said, "I love my job, I constantly see the scenery change around me, it refreshes my mind each and every day." Enjoying being in the moment and connecting to nature are such simple and rich resources for calming the mind, and don’t cost us a single thing. If you want to find out more about our workshops, please email info@fionadunkley.com. Try to give yourself the gift of time, even for one day, and listen to your inner truth when sitting in your silence. Fiona Dunkley (Founder of FD Consultants) For organisations looking for employee psychological support, FD Consultants are the trauma specialists and well-being service who will best deliver a reliable, quick, and bespoke support system in the workplace. FD Consultant’s team of accredited specialists will offer ongoing support to help manage stress, prevent burnout and provide specialist trauma care where required, enabling your staff with the tools to cope, and recover more quickly. |
CONTACTArchives
October 2020
Categories
All
|